9mm vs .40 vs .45 for Concealed Carry: What Changes in the Gun You Carry
Share
Every caliber debate ends up in the same place: stopping power, and a lot of confident opinions about it. I’m going to skip most of that fight, because it’s the least useful part of the decision for someone who carries every day. The question that actually changes your life is smaller and more physical: what does the caliber you pick do to the size and weight of the gun on your belt?
That’s the part you’ll feel at hour ten of a workday, when you sit down in a truck, or when you try to hide a pistol under a T-shirt in July. It’s also the part that decides what kind of holster you need and where it can sit on your body.
For concealed carry, 9mm is the default for most people because it fits the most rounds and the least recoil into the smallest gun. A .40 S&W fits in nearly the same size gun as a 9mm but gives up a couple of rounds and adds snappier recoil. A .45 ACP usually means a longer, taller, heavier gun, or a smaller one with only 10 rounds. Whichever you choose, the holster has to be molded for that exact gun.

The ballistics, briefly
All three cartridges are proven, and with modern hollow points the differences in the target are smaller than the internet makes them sound. Ammo.com’s three-way comparison makes the case plainly: the FBI’s standard for defensive ammunition is 12 to 18 inches of penetration in ballistic gel, and quality defensive loads from Speer, Federal and Winchester meet it in all three calibers. Their conclusion is the one most instructors land on: shot placement matters more than caliber.
Here is what manufacturers list for a few representative loads, taken from Ammo.com’s ballistics tables. These are manufacturer figures from 4 and 5 inch test barrels, so your gun and your load will differ.
|
Load |
Muzzle velocity |
Muzzle energy |
|
9mm, 124 grain |
1,150 fps |
364 ft-lbs |
|
9mm, 147 grain |
990 fps |
320 ft-lbs |
|
.40 S&W, 165 grain |
1,150 fps |
485 ft-lbs |
|
.40 S&W, 180 grain |
1,000 fps |
400 ft-lbs |
|
.45 ACP, 185 grain |
1,000 fps |
410 ft-lbs |
|
.45 ACP, 230 grain |
880 fps |
396 ft-lbs |
The .40 does have the most energy on paper. That is its whole pitch, and it’s the reason it replaced the 9mm in so many police holsters in the 1990s. For the full data on any load, Ammo.com keeps a ballistics hub and a dedicated .40 S&W ballistics page.
The energy gap is real. What matters for carry is the price you pay to get it, and that’s where the gun comes in.
What each caliber does to the size of the gun
The cleanest way to see it is to put same-class Glocks side by side. Glock describes its G23 Gen5 as the .40 S&W equivalent of the G19 Gen5, which makes the pair a fair comparison for compact pistols, and the full-size G21 is the standard .45 reference.
|
Glock spec |
G19 Gen5 (9mm) |
G23 Gen5 (.40) |
G21 Gen4 (.45) |
|
Standard capacity |
15 |
13 |
13 |
|
Barrel |
4.02 in |
4.02 in |
4.61 in |
|
Slide length |
6.85 in |
6.85 in |
7.60 in |
|
Slide width |
1.00 in |
1.08 in |
1.12 in |
|
Height with magazine |
5.04 in |
5.08 in |
5.51 in |
|
Weight, empty magazine |
23.63 oz |
26.67 oz |
29.28 oz |
Sources: Glock’s published specs for the G19 Gen5, G23 Gen5 and G21 Gen4. Weights for the G19 and G23 come from retailer listings that reproduce Glock’s figures.
Three things jump out.
The .40 doesn’t make the gun bigger, but it makes it a little thicker and heavier. Same barrel, same slide length, almost the same height. You lose two rounds, add about three ounces, and the slide is 0.08 inch wider. That slide width matters more than it sounds. Glock itself warns on the G23 Gen5 page that the slide on its Gen5 .40 models is slightly wider than on the previous generation, and tells buyers to keep that in mind when choosing a holster.
The full-size .45 is bigger in every direction. The slide is three quarters of an inch longer, the grip is nearly half an inch taller, and the gun weighs more than five and a half ounces more than the 9mm with an empty magazine. That is a noticeable difference on a belt.
Capacity drops as you go up. Per Ammo.com’s comparison, a full-size Glock 17 carries 17 rounds of 9mm, a Glock 22 carries 15 of .40 and a Glock 21 carries 13 of .45.
Can a .45 be small?
Yes, and it’s worth being fair about it. The Glock 30S, a subcompact .45, is listed by Glock at 4.80 inches tall with a 6.77 inch slide, a 3.78 inch barrel and a 1.00 inch slide width. That is shorter than a G19 in both height and slide length. The catch is capacity (10 rounds against 15) and recoil.
That’s the tradeoff Ammo.com points out too: when you shrink a gun, you increase felt recoil. Their example is that a .45 that feels comfortable in a full-size 1911 gets much harder to control in a Glock 36, and a .40 that’s merely lively in a Glock 22 becomes unpleasant in a Glock 27. A small 9mm gives you more rounds and less recoil in the same footprint. Ammo.com’s number is that 9mm has about 25 percent less recoil than .40 S&W, and about half the recoil of .45 ACP in comparable guns.
Where the gun sits on your belt
This is the part that connects the caliber to your day.
A longer slide hangs lower inside the waistband, which you notice most when you sit. A taller grip rides higher and shows more through a shirt. A heavier gun pulls on the belt and tilts toward your hip. Add those up and the .45 full-size is a different carry experience from a compact 9mm, not just a different cartridge.
That is why the placement choices matter more with the bigger guns. If you carry appendix, a long slide finds your thigh, and Appendix Carry vs Strong Side explains how position changes what prints. The weight question is a belt question, and How Your Belt Impacts Concealed Carry covers why a stiff belt matters more as the gun gets heavier. If the grip is what shows, How to Prevent Printing When Concealed Carrying covers the fixes, and What Makes a Holster Comfortable explains why the gun’s weight and shape drive the holster design.
What it means for your holster
A holster is built around the exact shape of the gun, and caliber changes that shape in ways that are easy to miss.

Take Glock’s own warning about the Gen5 .40 slide. A holster made for a 9mm Glock of the same size isn’t automatically right for the .40, because the slide is wider. The same goes for the .45: a longer slide, a taller grip and a wider slide all change what the shell has to hold.
CYA treats these as separate models. The model finder lists the Glock 22, Glock 23 (both Gen 3-4 and Gen5) and Glock 27 for .40, and the Glock 36 and the M&P 45 Shield for .45, each as its own entry. The Glock 19 RIDGE IWB lists the Glock 19 and Glock 19 MOS, each with a 4.02 inch barrel. That’s the point of molding to the specific gun: the same holster shouldn’t be assumed to carry a different model.
“Fit perfectly, love the holster.” Antonio E., verified buyer, on the Glock 19 RIDGE IWB
“Second holster of this style. One for a 365x macro and one for G19 gen 4. Both are great, especially at the price point.” Mike L. I., verified buyer, on the same holster
I’m quoting these on the 9mm side because that’s where most CYA buyers are, and it matches what the data says: most people carrying every day are carrying a compact 9mm. If you carry a .40 or .45, use the holster finder to confirm your exact model is covered before you order, and browse the Glock IWB collection from there. Every CYA holster is molded on the real pistol it’s named for, in 0.080 inch Boltaron.
Cost and availability
Ammo is where the practical gap is widest, and it matters more than most buyers expect, because skill comes from practice and practice costs money. Ammo.com says 9mm ammunition runs about half the price of .45 ACP, and that 9mm FMJ is generally cheaper than .40. They also note that many law enforcement agencies are moving back from .40 to 9mm.
You can see the spread for yourself by comparing 9mm ammo, .40 S&W ammo and .45 ACP ammo, or by pricing a case of bulk 9mm against bulk .40 S&W and bulk .45 ACP. For carry loads, 9mm hollow points and .45 ACP hollow points are where most defensive ammunition lives, and Ammo.com’s best .45 ACP hollow points roundup is a good place to start if you carry one.
Whatever you carry, test your defensive load in your own gun. That advice is the same for every caliber.
So which should you carry?
Choose 9mm if you want the least recoil, the most rounds and the widest choice of carry-size guns and holsters. For most people, it’s the answer. Ammo.com’s own guide to the best concealed carry caliber lands there too.
Choose .40 S&W if you already own and shoot one well. The gun is about the same size as a compact 9mm, but you carry fewer rounds, deal with snappier recoil and pay more per round. It’s a reasonable choice you already made, not the one I’d start with today.
Choose .45 ACP if you like it and you’re willing to accept a larger gun or fewer rounds. It’s a fine carry caliber in the right gun, especially if you carry on the strong side with a good belt and have room to hide a bigger frame.
If you’re still undecided between other options, our guides on choosing a caliber for concealed carry, .380 vs 9mm, .357 SIG vs 9mm and 5.7x28 vs 9mm cover the rest of the field. For a gun to match the caliber, start with the best concealed carry guns and micro-compact vs. compact pistols.
For deeper side-by-side comparisons of the cartridges themselves, Ammo.com has dedicated pages for 9mm vs .40, 9mm vs .45 and .40 vs .45.
The best caliber is the one you can shoot accurately, carry every day and afford to practice with. The gun around it decides most of that.
Frequently asked questions
Is 9mm or .45 better for concealed carry?
For most people, 9mm. It gives more rounds, less recoil and lower ammo cost in a gun of the same size. A .45 can work well, but it usually means a bigger gun or fewer rounds.
Is .40 S&W a good concealed carry caliber?
It works, and it has the most muzzle energy of the three on paper. The tradeoffs are snappier recoil, fewer rounds than a 9mm and higher ammo cost. A compact .40 is almost the same size as a compact 9mm.
Is a .40 the same size as a 9mm?
In same-class guns, nearly. The Glock 23 Gen5 matches the Glock 19 Gen5 in barrel and slide length, with a slightly wider slide and about three more ounces of weight.
Does a .45 need a bigger holster?
In a full-size gun, yes. The slide, grip and frame are all bigger, and a holster is molded for the specific model.
Can I use the same holster for a 9mm and the .40 version of the same gun?
Not automatically. Glock notes that the slide on its Gen5 .40 models is slightly wider than before, so check the maker’s compatibility list for your exact model.
How much recoil difference is there between 9mm and .45?
Ammo.com puts 9mm recoil at roughly half that of .45 ACP in comparable guns, and about a quarter lower than .40 S&W. Gun weight changes that, and small guns recoil harder.
Which caliber is cheapest to practice with?
9mm. Ammo.com says it costs about half as much as .45 ACP, and 9mm FMJ is generally cheaper than .40.
What matters more, the caliber or the gun?
The gun. Size, weight, capacity and fit decide whether you carry it every day, and carrying it every day is what counts.
Justin Hunold
Firearms Writer and Firearms Expert
Justin Hunold is a firearms writer and lifelong shooter who spent more than ten years behind the gun counter at Bass Pro Shops and Dick's Sporting Goods, helping thousands of customers — first-time handgun buyers, everyday concealed carriers, hunters, competitive shooters, and law enforcement officers — find the firearm and gear that actually fit their needs.