Which Slim 9mm Should You Carry? Glock 43X vs 48 vs Hellcat Pro vs Glock 26
Share
The slim 9mm category has gotten crowded in a hurry. Five years ago, you picked between a handful of guns. Now four very different pistols are all fighting for the same spot on your belt, and the search data shows how many people are trying to sort them out: 43X vs 48, 43X vs Hellcat Pro, 43X vs 26, and plenty of “which one is closer to a Glock 19” questions on top of that.
I want to give you a straight comparison, and I want to do it from the angle I know best, which is how the size of each gun changes the way it carries and what the holster has to do about it. A spec sheet will tell you how long a barrel is. It won’t tell you what happens to that barrel when you sit down in a truck with the gun at your appendix.
For most people carrying inside the waistband every day, the choice comes down to what you want from the size. The Glock 43X is the balanced pick. The Glock 48 gives up some concealment for a longer sight radius and a steadier shooting platform. The Springfield Hellcat Pro packs the most rounds (15+1) into a slim frame. The Glock 26 is the shortest in the grip but the thickest of the four. Whichever you choose, each one needs a holster molded for that exact gun, because the differences between them are small enough to cause real fit problems.
The four guns at a glance
|
Glock 43X |
Glock 48 |
Hellcat Pro |
Glock 26 |
|
|
Capacity (flush mag) |
10+1 |
10+1 |
15+1 |
10+1 |
|
Barrel |
3.41 in |
4.17 in |
3.7 in |
3.43 in |
|
Overall length |
6.50 in |
7.28 in |
6.6 in |
6.50 in |
|
Height |
5.04 in |
5.04 in |
4.8 in |
4.17 in |
|
Width |
about 1.10 in |
about 1.10 in |
1.0 in |
about 1.26 in |
Two things jump out at me. First, the 43X and 48 share the same frame, so they have the same height and grip. Glock’s own announcement of the two guns says exactly that: the same frame size with different slide lengths, 6.06 inches on the 43X and 6.85 on the 48. Second, the Hellcat Pro is the sleeper of the group on paper. Springfield lists it at 15+1, 4.8 inches tall, and just 1 inch wide, which makes it shorter in the grip than the Glocks, higher in capacity, and the narrowest body of the four. The Glock 26 is the opposite: very short in the grip, but noticeably wider through the frame.
Let me walk through each matchup the way I’d explain it across a table.
Glock 43X vs Glock 48
This is the comparison people ask about most, and it’s the easiest one to explain. The 43X and 48 use the same frame. The 48 just wears a longer slide and barrel, with the barrel stretching from about 3.41 inches to 4.17.
What does that extra three quarters of an inch buy you? A longer sight radius, a bit more weight up front, and a gun that most people find a little easier to shoot well. It also costs you in two places: overall length (7.28 inches versus 6.50) and carry. When I think about an IWB holster for each, the 48 has more gun hanging below the belt, which matters most when you’re seated or bending over. With the gun at your appendix, a longer muzzle is the thing that finds your thigh. If you carry that way, Appendix Carry vs Strong Side breaks down how placement changes what hides and what prints.
The 43X, by contrast, is the gun I’d point most people toward when they ask for one slim Glock. It’s easier to carry all day and it shoots well enough that you’re not giving up much. We lay out the case in Is the Glock 43X the Best EDC Gun?. If you’re a larger-handed person or you plan to shoot the gun a lot, the 48 is a very reasonable answer. But you’ll feel the extra length.
“I have several of these holsters. Best inside the waist band holsters on the market.” Darwin P., verified buyer, on the Glock 48 Ridge IWB
Glock 43X vs Hellcat Pro
This is a different kind of comparison, because you’re stepping outside the Glock family. The Hellcat Pro runs a 3.7 inch barrel and a 15+1 flush-fit magazine in a body that’s about a tenth of an inch narrower than the 43X, at 6.6 inches long and 4.8 inches tall.
So the Hellcat Pro is a little shorter in the grip than the 43X, holds five more rounds, and is a touch slimmer. That’s a lot of capacity for the size, and it’s why this gun keeps showing up in these conversations. The tradeoffs are mostly personal. Some people prefer Glock’s controls, trigger, and aftermarket support. Others like the Hellcat Pro’s grip texture and the extra rounds. If you want a deeper look at how it stacks up against another high-capacity slim gun, we compared it in SIG P365 X-Macro vs. Hellcat Pro.

From a holster standpoint, the Hellcat Pro has a different shape. It’s not a Glock, so you shouldn’t expect a Glock holster to work. The grip, trigger guard, and slide profile are all its own, and the holster has to be built around those. This is exactly the sort of case where “it’s about the same size” doesn’t mean “the same holster.” We cover carrying it comfortably in Best Hellcat Holster for Concealed Carry.
“Excellent holster. Fits like a glove.” William C., verified buyer, on the Hellcat Pro 3.7" Ridge IWB
Glock 43X vs Glock 26
Here’s the matchup that surprises people, because the Glock 26 is the older and more traditional design. It’s a double-stack subcompact with a short grip, a 3.43 inch barrel, and a 10+1 capacity that you can stretch by dropping in Glock 17 or 19 magazines. At about 4.17 inches tall, it has the shortest grip of the four.
The catch is width. The 26 is roughly 1.26 inches wide, compared with about 1.10 for the 43X and 1.0 for the Hellcat Pro. That doesn’t sound like much until you’ve got it pressed against your body for ten hours. The 26 is a short gun that carries thick, and the 43X is a taller gun that carries thin. What Makes a Holster Comfortable goes into why those small differences add up over a full day.
There’s also a practical difference in the grip. The 26’s short grip means a lot of people hang a pinky off the bottom of it unless they run a magazine with a finger extension, and any magazine that sticks out of the bottom changes how a holster needs to be shaped around the grip. If you’ve ever wondered why the holster for the same gun feels different with an extended mag, that’s the reason.
“The fit was perfect and the retention is also.” Jeffrey W., verified buyer, on the Glock 26 Ridge IWB
What about the Glock 19?
A lot of the searches that lead people here include the Glock 19, so I’ll address it directly. The 19 is the benchmark almost everyone measures a carry gun against. It’s wider (about 1.26 inches, the same as the 26), at roughly 7.36 inches it’s a hair longer than even the 48, and it holds 15+1 as standard. Its 5.04 inch grip height matches the 43X and 48.
The slim guns in this lineup are attempts to give you something close to a 19’s shootability in less space. The 48 gets closest in feel, since its slide and barrel are nearest to the 19’s proportions. The Hellcat Pro matches the 19’s capacity in a smaller footprint. And the 43X sits at the compact end, trading a bit of shootability for carry comfort. For the 19 against another slim high-capacity gun, see Glock 19 vs. SIG P365 X-Macro, and for the gun on its own, our Glock 19 Gen 3 review.
How the size of each gun changes your holster
Here’s the part I think gets overlooked in most comparisons. When you pick a gun, you’re also picking a set of holster requirements, and the dimensions above translate directly into them.
Grip height decides ride height. The 43X, 48, and Hellcat Pro all have grips in the 4.8 to 5.04 inch range, which means a good amount of gun above the belt line. Where the holster sits, and how much of the grip shows or prints, depends on that height. The Glock 26, at 4.17 inches, has far less grip above the belt, which helps concealment and hurts how well you can grab it. The sweat guard matters here too, because it’s the part of the holster that covers the grip side. We explain the options in Holster Sweat Guard Explained.
Barrel length decides what happens below the belt. The 48’s longer slide and barrel mean more muzzle end hanging down in an IWB holster. For appendix carry, that’s the first place you’ll feel it. The shorter guns tuck away more easily.
Width decides how the holster sits against your body. A thinner gun gives you more room to work with, and a thicker one pushes the holster outward. The Glock 26’s extra width matters most in appendix carry, where there’s very little space to hide it.
Magazine choice changes the grip shell. On the Glock 26 especially, whether you run a flush mag or a longer one changes what the bottom of the holster has to accommodate.
Retention depends on the exact shape. All four of these guns have slim, tight profiles, and slim guns have very little margin. There’s less surface for a holster to grip, so small differences in the mold show up quickly as loose or inconsistent retention. That’s the core argument of Best IWB Holster: Stop Buying the List, Start Buying the Fit.
This is why I’m so particular about molds. A lot of holster makers build on blue guns and then label one holster as fitting several models. With guns this close in size, that shortcut shows. You can see it in our own lineup: the Glock 43 BASE IWB and the Glock 43X BASE IWB are two separate shells, because a small grip difference matters.
How CYA builds for each one
We don’t mold on blue guns, and we don’t use one mold to cover several pistols. We own the real firearms in-house, so each holster is molded on the real gun it’s named for. The Glock 43X, the Glock 48, the Springfield Hellcat Pro 3.7", and the Glock 26 each get their own shell, which means the grip, trigger guard, and retention points are matched to the actual pistol you carry, not a family average. The Ridge for the 43X and the Ridge for the Hellcat Pro both hold a 4.9 out of 5 rating across 15 reviews each.
“Great, comfortable fit. Fits raised sights, optics ready all around a great IWB holster. I’ve been a long time user of CYA products and won’t use anything else!” Alonzo S., verified buyer, on the Glock 43X Ridge IWB

Our holsters are made from 0.080 inch Boltaron, a thermoplastic in the same family as Kydex. If you’ve been shopping for a Kydex holster, Boltaron is abrasion resistant, chemical resistant, and holds its shape better in high heat. But the material only matters if the mold underneath it is right for your gun, and that’s where slim pistols leave the least room for error.
So which one should you carry?
Here’s how I’d sort it, as one person’s opinion.
Pick the Glock 43X if you want the balanced answer. It’s slim, easy to carry, and shoots well. It’s the one I’d suggest if you’re unsure.
Pick the Glock 48 if you want the most shootable gun of the four and you’re willing to carry a longer slide. It’s the same frame as the 43X with more barrel.
Pick the Hellcat Pro if capacity matters to you. Fifteen rounds in a body this narrow is hard to beat, and it’s a smart pick if you don’t have strong brand loyalty to Glock.
Pick the Glock 26 if you want the shortest grip and the option to run Glock full-size magazines, and you’re okay with a thicker gun against your body.
Whichever one you choose, get a holster built for that exact gun. At this size, a “close enough” holster is the fastest way to turn a great carry pistol into one you stop wanting to wear. Then run your carry load through it before you trust it. 9mm hollow point ammo is where most defensive loads live, and 9mm range ammo keeps the practice affordable.
“Great holster with great retention. Very easy to manipulate and tweak to your specific needs.” Chandler, on the Glock 43X Ridge IWB
Browse the full Glock IWB collection or the Springfield Armory IWB collection, or start with the Glock 43X BASE IWB, Glock 48 BASE IWB, Hellcat Pro BASE IWB, or Glock 26 BASE IWB.
Frequently asked questions
Which is better for concealed carry, the Glock 43X or the Glock 48?
They share the same frame, so the difference is the slide. The 43X is shorter and easier to conceal. The 48 has a longer barrel and slide, which many people find easier to shoot accurately but harder to carry comfortably.
Is the Springfield Hellcat Pro better than the Glock 43X?
It depends on what you value. The Hellcat Pro holds 15+1 rounds in a body slightly shorter and narrower than the 43X. The 43X has the Glock controls, trigger, and a large aftermarket. Neither is universally better.
Is the Glock 26 thicker than the 43X?
Yes. The Glock 26 is about 1.26 inches wide compared with about 1.10 for the 43X, and it’s a double-stack gun. It has a shorter grip but carries thicker.
Can I use the same holster for a Glock 43X and a Glock 48?
They share a frame but not a slide length, and a holster shaped for one will not match the other. A holster molded for the exact model is the better choice. The Glock 43X and Glock 48 each have their own.
Are CYA holsters made of Kydex?
No. CYA holsters are made from 0.080 inch Boltaron, a thermoplastic in the same family as Kydex that holds its shape better in heat and has a smoother surface.
Justin Hunold
Firearms Writer and Firearms Expert
Justin Hunold is a firearms writer and lifelong shooter who spent more than ten years behind the gun counter at Bass Pro Shops and Dick's Sporting Goods, helping thousands of customers — first-time handgun buyers, everyday concealed carriers, hunters, competitive shooters, and law enforcement officers — find the firearm and gear that actually fit their needs.